Originally posted on March 30, 2018 at baldilocks blog.
By the way, I’ll get around to posting about my charming guest later on today.
Human beings naturally gravitate to tribalism - racial, ethnic, and national varieties, of course, but the list is endless. And, we tend to believe that almost all types of tribalism have virtue. But, with us being a species endowed with higher thinking and, conversely one in which every single member is prone to error, it follows that almost all tribalism is at odds with the truth.
Naturally. Almost.
The best example of the effects of tribalism is any shooting incident involving Law Enforcement Officers. For those prone to tribal thinking, the personal tribal member is always a good guy when he/she dies and members of another tribe are always the bad guy when he/she dies. And both opinions depend on tribal affiliations. The standard examples:
The race(s) of the LEO(s)
The race(s) of the civilian(s) in the incident
The race(s) of the observers and commentators
These earthly tribal groupings tend to stomp objective truth. And, if anyone tries to insert truth into any discussion of this type, the shame-mongers and truth-stompers come out in force. The flag must be defended at all costs!
My friend, Steve Graham, once said that, for Christians, Christ is our race, creed and color. Not only is this confirmed in Galatians 3:28, but in the very essence of God's being, illustrated by one of His names –Jehovah Nissi; God is my Banner. It is the only type of tribalism that is based on unshakable truth. “I am the Way, the Truth and the Life.” And anyone can become a member of this tribe.
When other types of tribalism are the foundation, the only objective truth is that error will be present.
And, the paradox is that, sometimes, error will infect an entire tribe and become that tribe's banner -- like a disease that has only one cure.
Juliette: " ... the paradox is that, sometimes, error will infect an entire tribe and become that tribe's banner -- like a disease that has only one cure."
Error makes a better marker of tribal membership than truth. Anyone will say "2 + 2 = 4". If my tribe insists that you add the qualifier "except when t's seven", I will recognize members of my tribe instantly.
Anyone might wear sensible clothes. Prescribe a strange hat as customary and members of the tribe will be instantly recognizable.
Related: George Stigler and Gary Becker, "De Gustibus non est Disputandem".
I hope I’ll see you at threadfedt2! ❤️✌🏽